Welp, ordered these shoes and found that they are drastically different in size than the ones they are supposed to replace. (Sorry, I wrote on them for the rental program).

Brand new out of box, cannot return. 

$65 each plus $5 shipping (just trying to recoup costs to buy the right size shoes!)

Red Chili's - size 5 -  $25 plus $5 shipping: these are lightly used with tons of rubber/life left.